Mugshot of Aaron Spencer, the Arkansas father arrested for allegedly shooting and killing a man found with his missing teenage daughter.

Arkansas Father Arrested After Fatal Shooting of Man Found With His Missing Teenage Daughter

An Arkansas father, Aaron Spencer, 36, was taken into custody after allegedly shooting and killing a man, Michael Fosler, 67, who was found in a vehicle with Spencer's missing 14-year-old daughter. The tragic incident unfolded on October 8, after Spencer reported his daughter missing and took matters into his own hands by tracking her location.

The Search for the Missing Daughter

According to the Lonoke County Sheriff’s Office, deputies were dispatched to Spencer’s home shortly after he reported his teenage daughter missing. While authorities were responding, Spencer managed to track down his daughter, who was found in a car with Fosler. A confrontation between the two men escalated, leading to Spencer allegedly shooting Fosler.

The Arrest and Charges

Following the incident, Spencer was arrested on one preliminary charge of first-degree murder and was booked into the Lonoke County Detention Center. The case has since garnered significant attention, with many questioning the circumstances surrounding the fatal shooting.

Disturbing Allegations Surface

Heather Spencer, Aaron's wife, called the arrest "outrageous" and shared alarming details in a GiveSendGo campaign. She claimed that months prior, their daughter, then 13, had been “groomed and raped” by Fosler, who was reportedly the boyfriend of a family friend. Heather explained that Fosler was facing multiple charges related to the abuse and was under a "no contact order." Despite this, Fosler allegedly continued to contact the teenager while free on bond.

“We let the justice system do its job. The monster who hurt our child was charged quickly, but released even faster on a $50k bond,” Heather wrote. She further revealed that Fosler was awaiting trial for several felony charges in connection to the abuse.

The Events Leading to the Fatal Confrontation

The Spencers reported their daughter missing after being woken up by her dog, which they found unusual. Heather recalled, “This is unusual and caused us to check on her. In that moment, we lived every parent’s biggest fear as we realized our teen child was missing.”

Aaron Spencer immediately began searching for their daughter, tracking her down to a vehicle where she was allegedly being held by Fosler. A high-speed chase ensued, ending in a collision. According to Heather, Fosler attempted to flee once he realized Spencer was pursuing him.

“As soon as the predator knew my husband was behind him, he ran. The chase ended in an accident,” Heather explained. Spencer managed to retrieve his daughter, but a confrontation with Fosler followed, resulting in Fosler’s death. Heather defended her husband’s actions, stating, “He did what he had to do to protect himself and our minor child.”

A Father’s Defense

Heather described her husband as a hero, expressing her belief that their daughter might not have made it home safely if Aaron hadn’t acted. "I have no doubt our child would have not come home if my husband hadn’t found her," she wrote, adding that Aaron is a military veteran who acted out of necessity to protect their child.

Spencer was later released on a $150,000 bond, but the case remains under investigation.

Legal Proceedings Await

In a press conference, Lonoke County Sheriff John Staley addressed the situation, calling it a "tragic" case. He emphasized that it will be up to the Lonoke County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office to determine whether or not to pursue formal charges against Spencer. Sheriff Staley offered his “thoughts and prayers” to all those affected by the incident.

This case has sparked widespread debate, with many considering whether Spencer’s actions were justified given the circumstances. As the investigation continues, the outcome will hinge on the prosecuting attorney’s decision and the legal proceedings that follow.

By highlighting the allegations against Fosler, the emotional plea of Spencer’s wife, and the legal complexities of the case, this story has drawn national attention. For more updates on this case, follow the latest developments and stay informed about key legal decisions.

Back to blog
1 of 3